In the print dialog pick “Save as PDF” to keep it on your phone. A5 makes a pocket booklet; A4 suits a desk printer.
Voykit pocket guide · United States
Shelter Island
Go for 2 nights by car or bike, May–Oct: no town centre, no bus, and the last ferries leave around midnight.
Shelter Island is a 6.5 sq mi town between the North and South Forks of Long Island, reached only by the North Ferry from Greenport or the South Ferry from North Haven. There is no village core and no public bus: you drive, cycle or walk. Two nights covers the beaches, Mashomack Preserve and a slow loop; one night works if you arrive early and leave late.
- Country
- United States
- Best months
- May–Jun, Sep–Oct
- Avoid
- Jul–Aug (crowds, ferry queues, peak room rates), Nov–Apr (many places closed)
- Stay
- 2 nights
Checked 2026-09. Prices, hours and rules change; anything marked (check) is not confirmed.
Essentials
- Currency
- USD
- Money
- Currency is the US dollar (USD, $). Cards and phone payments work almost everywhere; carry a little cash for tips and small vendors.
- Daily spend
- Budget $90–150 excl. bed · Mid $150–280 excl. bed · High $280+ excl. bed (estimate; check)
- SIM and data
- AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile cover the country; prepaid SIMs at their stores and Walmart/Target (passport required), or an eSIM before you fly.
- Emergency
- Police, fire, ambulance 911 · Poison Control 1-800-222-1222
- Plugs
- Types A, B · 120 V · 60 Hz · Chargers are dual-voltage; hair dryers and straighteners from 230 V countries need a converter.
- Tipping
- Sit-down restaurant: 18–22% of the pre-tax bill.; Bar: US$1–2 per drink or 20% of the tab.; Taxi / ride-hailing: 15–20%, in the app.; Hotel housekeeping: US$3–5 a night.; Porter / valet: US$2–5 per bag or car.; Tour guide: US$10–20 per person for a day tour.; Counter service / tablet prompts: Optional; 0–15%.
- Water
- Tap water is drinkable nearly everywhere; boil or treat water from streams in parks.
- Toilets
- Free public toilets are scarce in big cities; use cafés, department stores, libraries, stations. Rest areas on highways are free.
What things cost
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Coffee | $4–7 |
| Deli sandwich | $10–16 |
| Pizza, one pie | $18–28 |
| Sit-down dinner, main | $25–45 |
| Beer at a bar | $8–12 |
| Ferry crossing, car and driver | about $20 (check) |
| Bike rental, one day | $35–60 (check) |
Desk estimates, checked 2026-09; check locally.
Get in
By air
- ISP · Long Island MacArthur (Islip)
- About 1 h 15 min by car to the North Ferry, then the crossing
- JFK · John F. Kennedy International
- About 2 h 30 min by car to Greenport in summer traffic
- LGA · LaGuardia
- About 2 h 30 min by car to Greenport
Typical fares
- North Ferry, Greenport → Shelter Island, car and driver
- about $20 one way (check)
- South Ferry, North Haven → Shelter Island, car and driver
- about $20 one way (check)
- Taxi across the island
- $15–30 (check)
Show 7 more sections and the pocket cardHideGet around, See and do, Sleep, Phrase card, Etiquette, safety and scams, One and two days, Sources, Pocket card
Get around
Car, bike or foot only. The island is about 6.5 sq mi with two-lane roads and no public bus; taxis are few, so book ahead or plan to cycle. Bikes can cross on both ferries. Distances are short: North Ferry to South Ferry is roughly 15 min by car.
See and do
Known for
- Mashomack Nature Preserve
- Crescent Beach and Kissing Rock
- North and South Ferries
- Quiet bays, no chain hotels
Day trips
| Where | How | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Greenport | North Ferry from Shelter Island, about 10 min, then walk into the village | About 30 min |
| Sag Harbor | South Ferry, then about 15 min by car via Route 114 | About 40 min |
| Montauk | South Ferry, then Route 114 and Route 27 east | About 1 h 30 min |
| Westhampton Beach | South Ferry, then Route 114 and Route 27 west | About 1 h 15 min |
Sleep
- Shelter Island Heights
- South Ferry side; inns, the Heights historic district and Crescent Beach within a short drive.
- Shelter Island Center
- The IGA, pharmacy and most year-round services; central for driving anywhere on the island.
- West Neck and Shore Road
- Waterfront hotels and the sunset side on Peconic Bay; car needed for everything.
Phrase card
| English | Say or show |
|---|---|
| Where is the ferry? | Where is the ferry? |
| One ticket, please | One ticket, please |
| Can I pay by card? | Can I pay by card? |
| Is there a taxi? | Is there a taxi? |
| What time is the last ferry? | What time is the last ferry? |
Etiquette, safety and scams
Etiquette
- Greeting: Handshake and 'hi, how are you?' — reply 'good, thanks'; avoid: Treating the question as a real health enquiry
- Restaurants: Tip 18–22% and wait for the check; avoid: Leaving without tipping
- Personal space: Keep an arm's length in queues; avoid: Standing close to strangers
- Politics and religion: Listen more than you speak; avoid: Opening with hot-button topics
- Smoking: Smoke only in marked areas; avoid: Smoking near doors or in parks where banned
Scams and watch-outs
- Ferry queues back up on summer weekends: arrive early for the North Ferry from Greenport.
- Many restaurants and inns close or cut hours from November to April: check before booking.
- Roads are narrow with no shoulders in places; ride single file and use lights.
- Cell coverage is patchy in parts of Mashomack Preserve.
- Ticks are present in woods and tall grass: use repellent and check after walks.
Very low crime; the real risks are narrow roads shared with cars, ticks in the woods, and summer heat on exposed beaches.
One and two days
No timed day plan for Shelter Island yet. Suggested stay: 2 nights. Build a day from the list below, mornings for the big sight.
- Mashomack Nature Preserve
- Crescent Beach and Kissing Rock
- North and South Ferries
- Quiet bays, no chain hotels
Sources
Written by Voykit; facts cross-checked against these sources, last desk check 2026-09. Prices, hours and rules change: check on the day.
- Town of Shelter Island: www.shelterislandtown.us/
- Wikivoyage: Shelter Island, revision 4210133 (CC BY-SA 4.0): en.wikivoyage.org/w/index.php?oldid=4210133
Pocket card
Cut along the border and keep it in your wallet. Show the local-script lines to a driver.
Shelter Island
To this address, please
To this address, please
My hotel (write the name and address in the local script)
- Police, fire, ambulance911
- Poison Control1-800-222-1222
No consulates on the island; nearest are in New York City. US visitors: 911 for anything urgent.
Tipping: 18–22% at sit-down restaurants, $1–2 a drink, 15–20% taxis.
Voykit · checked 2026-09
Printed from Voykit (/shelter-island). Written by Voykit; checked 2026-09. Estimates only: confirm prices, hours and entry rules on the day.